Bellona nuclear digest. July 2024
A survey of events in the field of nuclear and radiation safety relating to Russia and Ukraine.
News
Publish date: November 14, 2005
Written by: Charles Digges
News
European negotiators with the European Union (EU) and the United States were reportedly willing to accept the arrangement as a compromise to allow Iran to move ahead with its nuclear programme while ensuring it does not produce nuclear weapons. Enrichment can produce material for bombs and for nuclear reactor fuel.
The fuel would presumably be used in the Bushehr reactor on the Persian Gulf, which has been under construction with Russian co-operation for nearly the past decade. The light water reactor has been a thorn in the side of the US security establishment, and a bone of heated contention between Moscow and Washington, which has repeatedly demanded that Russia cease nuclear co-operation with Iran. Moscow has insisted that Irans nuclear programme is for peaceful purposes, and may help the country build some five more reactors once Bushehr is completed.
But even Moscow, who has counted on Iran as a market for its own uranium fuel, has since 2002 been arguing with Iran about who will maintain control of the fuel once it has been burned. Moscow had initially intended to produce Bushehrs fuel and take the spent nuclear fuel (SNF) back to Russia for reprocessing. But Tehran steadily began to cool on that idea to such a degree that Moscow has even offered to pay Iran for Bushehrs eventual (SNF). The reactor is some 80 percent complete.
These hassles now appear to be moot as Iran has announced its intentions to enrich its own uranium, taken from reopened mines in the country and enrich it to fuel levels.
But Aghazadeh flatly rejecting Russiasor any other countrysinvitation to enrich uranium abroad, AP reported.
“What is important for us is that we be entrusted to carry out enrichment in Iran. As for participation by other countries in Iran’s uranium enrichment programme, we will consider it if there are any proposals,” he said.
When asked if Tehran would agree to enrichment being carried out abroad, Aghazadeh said, “Iran’s nuclear fuel will be produced inside Iran.”
Iranian foreign ministry spokesman Hamid Reza Asfi seconded Aghazadeh, saying Sunday that “Enrichment should be carried out on Iranian soil, as other Iranian officials have said before,” he told reporters.
The rejected compromise
Under the proposal that was floated by Russia to help ease the tension with the EU and United States, Iran would be allowed to carry out an initial step in making nuclear fuelconverting uranium ore into the uranium hexafluoride gas that is the feedstock for making enriched uranium.
But enrichment itself would be done in Russia under an offer said to have been favourably accepted by the
EU and the United States.
Iran says it only wants to enrich uranium to low levels for atomic reactor fuel and argues such work is a right enshrined by the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), of which the Islamic Republic is a signatory.
But the enrichment process can be diverted to military purposes, and the United States and European Union fear that Irans clerical regime is merely using an atomic energy drive as a cover for weapons development.
Iran already moving ahead to make enrichment possible
Iran has already taken initial steps to pave the way for uranium enrichment inside Iran.
Last week, Aghazadeh said Iran would give the outside world a 35 percent share in its uranium enrichment programme, allowing other countries to have a role in and monitor uranium enrichment at Iran’s facility in the centrally located town of Natanz, news agencies reported. Aghazadeh said at the time that giving other nations and foreign companies such a role was the “maximum concession” Tehran could offer.
In Vienna on Friday, a diplomat within the ranks of the UNs International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) confirmed that a position paper entitled “Elements of a Long-Term Solution” had been passed on to the Russians by the UN nuclear watchdog agency about a week ago, AP said.
The IAEA plans on November 24th to discuss whether to refer Iran to the UN Security Council for possible sanctions connected to its nuclear programme, representatives for the agency have said in recent week. .
Where Tehran ran afoul of the West
Iran triggered the latest stand-off in August when it effectively broke off negotiations on a package of incentives for restraining its nuclear plans and resumed conversion activities it had suspended a year ago.
The IAEA has demanded Iran return to a full freeze of enrichment-related work and return to negotiations with Britian, France and Germany. Iran says it is willing to negotiate, but not suspend all of its activities, AFP reported.
Asefi said Iran wanted to see a “balanced approach” to its nuclear programme, and repeated that talks needed to be widened to involve countries other than the so-called EU3.
He also reacted to reports that US intelligence officials have shown IAEA members a stolen Iranian laptop computer containing nuclear designs as proof the country is secretly pursuing a nuclear weapons programme.
The New York Times reported on its web site Saturday that during the demonstration of the laptops contents, which took place in Vienna in mid-July, officials displayed selections from more than a thousand pages of Iranian computer simulations and accounts of experiments, saying they showed a long effort to design a nuclear warhead.
“This is worthless and naive. We usually don’t carry our secrets around in laptops,” Asefi laughed when asked to respond to the report, AFP said.
A survey of events in the field of nuclear and radiation safety relating to Russia and Ukraine.
Transport on the Northern Sea Route is not sustainable, and Kirkenes must not become a potential hub for transport along the Siberian coast. Bellona believes this is an important message Norway should deliver in connection with the Prime Minister's visit to China. In an open letter to Jonas Gahr Støre, Bellona asks the Prime Minister to make it clear that the Chinese must stop shipping traffic through the Northeast Passage.
The International Atomic Energy Agency has published a new report on its efforts to ensure nuclear safety and security during the conflict in Ukraine, with the agency’s director-general warning that the situation at the Zaporizhzhia nuclear power station remains “precarious and very fragile.”
In this news digest, we monitor events that impact the environment in the Russian Arctic. Our focus lies in identifying the factors that contribute to pollution and climate change.